submarine/docs/state-model.md

State model

Code: internal/submodule/model.go, internal/submodule/status.go.

Three commits per submodule

Every submodule involves three commits. All state is derived from comparing them.

Commit	Source
Pinned	The gitlink recorded in the superproject index (differs from HEAD → PinStaged)
Checked out	The submodule's HEAD
Tip	The tip of the ref the pin was resolved to, e.g. origin/main

This gives two independent questions:

• Is the checkout on the pin? → off pin if not.
• Where is the pin relative to its ref? → ↑n / ↓n / ↑n↓m.

Raw status dimensions

submodule.Status stores the raw, independent dimensions. A submodule can be in several at once.

Field	Values
Presence	PresenceOK, NotInitialized, DirMissing
Checkout	CheckoutMatch, CheckoutDiffers, CheckoutDetached (on the pin, detached HEAD; informational)
Worktree	WorktreeClean, WorktreeModified, WorktreeUntracked, WorktreeConflict
PinStaged	Pin changed in the superproject index but not committed
Pin	Ref, Source, Ahead, Behind, Pushed
Pinned, CheckedOut, Tip	Commits (SHA, subject, author, time)
Between	Commits that make up the pin ↔ tip difference
Changes	Changed files of the worktree (nil if clean), see below
FetchedAt	Last fetch of the submodule (FETCH_HEAD mtime); zero if never

Submodule.FetchErr is set if the application's last fetch of the submodule failed. Like loading errors, it is not an issue kind: a failed fetch says nothing about the submodule's state.

Status == nil means "still loading". Submodule.Err is set if loading failed.

Changes

Status.Changes describes what is behind Worktree: one FileChange per path with a ChangeKind (conflicted, modified, added, removed, renamed, untracked), added/removed line counts, and flags for binary files and moved nested submodule pointers. It compares the worktree with HEAD, so staged and unstaged changes are combined (a file added to the index and edited afterwards is one added file).

• Files is sorted by kind (that order), then by changed lines (largest first), then by path, and capped at MaxChangeFiles (200). Total, Added and Removed cover all files.
• FileChange.Modified is the file's modification time (zero for removed files).
• Worktree is derived from the same list: conflict, else any tracked change → modified, else untracked.
• It is a preview, not an issue: it adds no issue kinds and changes no levels.

Issues: summarizing the dimensions

The UI never shows raw dimensions in the tree. Status.Issues() summarizes them into issue kinds, each with a level. This is the single source of truth for what counts as a problem.

Issue (word)	Combines	Level
unpushed	Pin not reachable from any remote ref	Danger
conflict	Merge conflict in the worktree	Danger
missing	Not initialized; directory missing	Warn
off pin	Checkout differs from pin	Warn
changed	Uncommitted changes; untracked files (worded "untracked repository" if all of them are git repositories)	Warn

Rules:

• If the submodule is missing, that is its only issue (nothing else can be determined).
• Issues are returned most severe first: unpushed, conflict, off pin, changed.
• Not issues (quiet): in sync, pin behind/ahead/diverged but pushed, staged pin, detached HEAD on the pin. They are shown as information only. A staged pin is also visible in the tree (staged or a ● marker), see ux-guide.md, but is never counted as an issue.
• A loading error is shown as error (Danger) in the UI; it is not an issue kind.

Levels

Level	Meaning	Presentation
LevelQuiet	Nothing to do	Whole row muted, no word
LevelWarn	Look at it	Yellow word
LevelDanger	Act now	Red bold word

Hidden issues

Submodule.HiddenIssues() counts the issues of all loaded descendants per level (Hidden{Warn, Danger}). A collapsed submodule shows them as ·k per level, red first, then yellow, so a danger can never hide inside a collapsed subtree and a warning is never mistaken for one. A descendant whose load failed (error) counts as one danger.

Superproject

The superproject is a node with an empty Path (Repo.Root, no children; Submodule.IsRoot()) and a Status with Root set. It reuses the pin fields with pin = HEAD: Pinned and CheckedOut are HEAD, Checkout is never CheckoutDiffers (CheckoutDetached for a detached HEAD), PinStaged is false. Issues() is the same code; only unpushed says "HEAD not pushed to any remote" (Danger, like a submodule's pin).

• Ref is the upstream of the current branch (RefFromCurrentBranch), so ahead/behind agrees with the header. Closest-branch resolution is only the fallback without an upstream (detached, or no upstream configured).
• Changes ignore submodules (status --ignore-submodules=all): an off-pin or staged submodule is shown by its own row, not twice. A leftover directory of a submodule the branch no longer has is an untracked repository.
• Walk and the header counts do not include the root.

Resolving a pin to a ref

The pin is displayed as a ref, not a hash. A commit can be on several branches, on none, or deep in the history. The git provider shows the closest branch and records which rule proposed it in PinInfo.Source.

Preferred refs, in this order (each only if it exists):

Preference	Ref	RefSource
a	branch = … in .gitmodules	RefFromGitmodules
b	Upstream of the branch checked out in the submodule	RefFromCurrentBranch
c	Remote default branch (<remote>/HEAD)	RefFromDefaultBranch

Resolution:

#	Rule	RefSource
1	Pin pushed: the branch containing the pin with the fewest commits after it. Candidates are the preferred refs that contain the pin plus any remote branch containing it (for-each-ref --contains); a tie goes to the preferred ref	preferred ref's, else RefFromContains
2	Pin unpushed: the preferred ref with the fewest commits on either side (↑n↓m), ties by preference	preferred ref's
3	A tag (git describe)	RefFromTag
4	Short SHA	RefFromSHA

So a .gitmodules branch is shown when it is as close as any other branch, but a pin that sits on a feature branch shows that branch rather than "diverged from main". The trade-off: a pin on main that a younger branch also contains shows the younger branch if its tip is fewer commits away.

Distances: git rev-list --left-right --count <pin>...<ref> gives Ahead (left) and Behind (right).

Pushed is true if the pin is reachable from any remote ref. A pin that is ahead of its ref can still be pushed (e.g. on another branch); only Pushed == false is dangerous.

Git commands

How the git provider (internal/submodule/git) fills Status. All commands are local; <pin> is the index gitlink.

Field	Command (in the parent repo / in the submodule)
Pinned, PinStaged	parent: ls-files -s -- <path> vs ls-tree HEAD -- <path>
Presence	directory missing → DirMissing; no .git in it → NotInitialized
Checkout	rev-parse HEAD, symbolic-ref -q HEAD (no branch → detached)
Worktree, Changes kinds	status --porcelain=v2 -z --untracked-files=normal --ignore-submodules=dirty
Changes line counts	diff HEAD --numstat -z -M --ignore-submodules=dirty, only if a tracked file changed; failure leaves the counts at 0
FileChange.Modified	stat of each changed file that still exists
Pushed	for-each-ref --contains <pin> refs/remotes is not empty
Pin.Ref	rules above; the remote is origin, else the first remote
Ahead, Behind	rev-list --left-right --count <pin>...<ref>
Between	log <pin>...<ref>, at most 50 commits

Details:

• Preference a: branch = . means the superproject's current branch. The ref counts only if <remote>/<branch> exists locally.
• Preference b uses the checked-out branch's upstream (<branch>@{upstream}).
• Rule 1 counts rev-list --count <pin>..<ref>. Besides the preferred refs it compares at most 16 containing branches (oldest tip first).
• Rule 2 counts rev-list --count <pin>...<ref>.
• Rule 4 shows the short SHA; there is no tip and no distance.
• --ignore-submodules=dirty: changes inside a nested submodule do not make its parent changed (D7), but a moved nested pin does.
• Renames are detected only for staged moves (git mv); an unstaged move is a removed file plus an untracked file. Untracked directories are one entry (dir/) without line counts.
• --untracked-files=normal overrides status.showUntrackedFiles, so the result doesn't depend on the user's config.
• A missing submodule only gets a Pinned SHA; nested submodules of an uninitialized submodule are unknown and not shown.
• If the pinned commit doesn't exist in the submodule (not fetched), loading fails with "pinned commit … not fetched" (shown as error) instead of guessing unpushed.

Distance notation

Display	Meaning
↓n	The ref has n commits the pin doesn't have; the pin is behind
↑n	The pin has n commits the ref doesn't have
↑n↓m	Diverged

The arrows follow the convention of git status, lazygit and shell prompts.